Join us on a journey to Nostalgia as we explore our incredible new lineup of super sandwiches, each one crafted with a unique combination of in-house made ingredients. At Nostalgia, we take pride in every step of the sandwich-making process, from brining and smoking our meats to perfection, all done on-site with no outside processing involved.

Our menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering options, including:

Pastrami on Rye: Classic and oh-so-delicious, served on your choice of bread.
Pulled Beef Burger: A savory delight that’ll satisfy your burger cravings.
Italian Burger: Bursting with Italian flavors and charm.
Roast Beef Sandwich: A hearty choice for those who love tender, slow-roasted beef.
BLT Sandwich (Beef Bacon, Lettuce, Tom): A twist on the classic BLT, featuring our signature beef bacon.
Kishke Pastrami and Sautéed Liver Sandwich: A unique and flavorful combination.
Pulled Beef on a Keier Roll Sandwich: Perfectly seasoned pulled beef on a fresh roll.
Breakfast Burger with Sunny Side Up: Start your day off right with this breakfast-inspired burger.
The Famous Nostalgia Burger: A true masterpiece, featuring Kishka, liver, pickles, and our secret sauce.
But that’s not all! We also offer a delightful selection of chicken poppers in various flavors, as well as fantastic options for birthday parties. As a special promotion, when you join us for a birthday dinner, you’ll receive a complimentary cake dessert to sweeten the celebration.

You can find us at 1200 River Ave., and we’re open every night until 10pm, with extended hours on Thursdays until 2am. If you can’t dine in with us, don’t worry – we offer outside catering services and are available on Uber Eats and other delivery platforms for your convenience.

For inquiries, reservations, or placing orders, give us a call at 732-705-9222. Join us at Nostalgia for an unforgettable dining experience that’ll transport you back in time!